Monday

What to expect in Primary One

When I was in primary one many years ago, the teacher only started to teach A, B, Cs. Many of my classmates did not go to kindergarten.

Kindergarten is still not compulsory now. But children are expected to know so much more before entering primary school.

My girl studies in a neighbourhood primary school in Jurong West. The school is using the Stellar program, which means that they use story books to teach English. Kids are not allowed to bring the story books back home. I asked the teacher and she showed me the story books in the classroom. The books are very simple, only one sentence of 5 to 6 words a page.

However, the school's English workbooks are not easy. The following photo shows a page from the workbook. A primary one child is expected to be able to read and understand a passage like this as early as February.
The child is expected to know how to answer these questions :


The following photo shows a question from the Maths workbook. Kids are expected to read and understand questions like this by March.

It takes a lot of time for kids to learn how to read this well. In order to read at this level, I believe that kids have to start learning the language no later than 3 years old. In fact, most parents start to send their kids to pre-schools from as young as 18 months old.

It is entirely possible to teach a child to read very well at home. In fact, no enrichment classes and pre-schools can promise this type of standards. Parents are the best teachers !



The following is a guide.

One to two years old :
First Step - Teaching A B C
It is very important for the child to know all the 26 phonics letter sounds very well. Do not rush the child, give him enough time to learn. My boy was only learning the 26 letters before he turned 3 years 3 months old.
At the same time, develop a love of books :
Wonderful books for kids from birth to 3 years old


Three to Four years old :
The child can start to learn phonics :
How to teach phonics
When the child knows how to join 3 letters to form a word, you must start teaching sight words using the Key Words (Peter and Jane) series :
Key Words with Ladybird

Five to Six years old :
Both my kids completed the Peter and Jane book 11 and 12 before they turned 5 years old. By then they are able to read long English novels. The child must continue to read out loud everyday, even after completing the Peter and Jane series. Parents should continue to choose good books that interest the kids :

Reading confidently at a very young age
Developing a love for reading
The importance of reading books

Note that every child progresses at a different pace, here is a guide :


If a child can complete the Peter and Jane book 6a and 6b before entering primary one, he is already very well prepared.

Teaching a child to read very well at a very young age, is not only about preparing for primary school. You are teaching the child the most valuable skill that will be essential for lifelong learning.

37 comments:

Joyce said...

Thanks, this is very useful as my elder son is entering P1 next year. I m quite concerned about the simple comprehension - looks like I have to pose some questions after going through stories with him (to see if he could answer in his own words).

purple dream said...

aHi, Tamarind,

thanks so much for your useful information. I wasn't as much concern on my gal's reading development, as she could comprehend stories, and also correctly point out some pictures with words, until the childcare teacher told me that she couldn't read and understand in her class, and the teachers have to repeat reading many times, and she was still does not show any confidence in reading.
I am extremely disappointed with this. I have been spending much time with her reading and not sure if she really need more time to be coached.

Tamarind said...

Dear purple dream,
My advise is to start a daily routine, and let your girl read out loud to you for at least 15 minutes everyday from a good book.

You can try the Ladybird Peter and Jane series :
Key Words with Ladybird

Or you can let her read any book that she likes. Just make sure that she reads every word out loud, this way you can help her if she does not know any word. If she can read out loud for at least 15 minutes every day, she will definitely improve.

Anonymous said...

Hi Tamarind,

You are really sooo nice to share relevant info with everyone.

By the way, have ur girl started creative writing? Or do they start later? I am thinking if it will be more challenging than comprehension.

Ur ardent blog fan....

Cheers... Melody

Tamarind said...

Dear Melody,
My older girl started to write her own little stories before she turned 5 years old. I have photos of what she wrote in this page :

Written by Chloe

I did not teach her how to write at all. My younger boy started to write compositions when he turned 5 years old. They write whenever they have new ideas.

Phonics is essential for writing. A child who has a strong foundation in phonics, and has read many books, will naturally know how to write without the need to be taught.

Tamarind said...

Dear Melody,
Forgot to add that in primary 1, kids are expected to start writing short compositions by the first half of the year.

Anonymous said...

OMG Tamarind ....I keep following now &? then ur blog ....it gives me great ideas as my kids are almost the same age as urs. Moreever we are to relocate frm US to SG this yr & I think its going to be monstrous jump for my DD, who will be going to Pri 1. Is the syllabus the same thru'out SG or differs frm school to school?

Tamarind said...

Quote :
"Is the syllabus the same thru'out SG or differs frm school to school?"

The P1 Syllabus is the same in every primary school, as in they should use the same textbooks. However, every school can have their own workbooks, and the standards of the questions/exercises in the workbooks differ from school to school.

ewok said...

You are frightening me.........
My gal will be P1 next year. She can read the Magic School Bus Chapter books series and Geronimo Stilton series. Does she still need to read the Peter and Jane series?

Her kindy teaches creative reading, will that help in composition?

Btw, which school is she attending?

Shirley said...

Tamarind

OMY...my girl cant really read yet! She is 6, starting P1 next year! I definitely need to speed things up.. btw, I stay in JW too, which sch is ur girl in?

Anonymous said...

Hi, Very useful post. Hope i had found it earlier :-)

Now my son is in K2, can read but is not interested in those reading books series. He is more into longer stories - like Timmy& topsy, curious george etc, which do have some words beyond his grasp. so he struggles on...

Wish i had paid more attention last year when i almost stopped reading to him , because of other committemnts...

Anyway, thank you for your effort to put together tips and guidlines . The compre passage did seem a bit high level for my son as of now. Will take a print out to see how much he can read and comprehend .

Anonymous said...

Hi,

What books would you recommend for a 3 year old?

poohger

Tamarind said...

Hi poohger,
At 3 years old, you should start by teaching phonics first :
How to teach phonics

The Ladybird key word series are the best books to teach a child to read :
Key Words with Ladybird

Tamarind said...

Also check out these wonderful books for 3 year old kids :
Wonderful book for kids

Tamarind said...

Dear all,
Both my kids learn to read very well using the Ladybird Key word series. They have a very strong foundation in phonics which helps make reading very easy for them. They are able to read words that they have not seen before by using phonics techniques.

Both my kids are reading long chapter books by the age of 5 years old :
The importance of reading books
Reading confidently at a very young age

The fact is that this is the best way to prepare a child for primary school. My girl has not done any English assessment books before entering primary school. Now at P1, she does not need to spend time studying English :)

My boy, who will be 6 years old this year, is able to spell all the words in my girl's spelling list for the first half of the year. He does not need to practice writing the words. He is able to spell easily using phonics.

If we start preparing a child early, using the correct methods as described in my blog : phonics and sight words, then the child will have no problem in primary school.

Anonymous said...

Hi Tamarind:

My DD is in P1 this year. Thanks to your blog, I went on a "crash course" last year using the Peter and Jane series, and together with her school, she was reading fine by Dec 09.

However, she recently had some tests, while both her Math and Chinese were both above 90, her English suffered terribly. I'm not sure if this was at the expense of spending too much time on the other 2 subjects or not spending enough time on English! Her school is using Stellar system and because they dont usually bring back the worksheets (and even the Grammar textbook) till late, I'm very clueless on her progress.
We read almost every night and she can read 7a, 7b without much difficulty. I'm in the "panic" zone now ;-( and dont know how to help her besides "drilling" more assessment papers on vocab, grammar and comprehension which are something not enjoyable and killing her interest...any suggestions?

PS: I've already started 3.5yr old DS on the letter sounds and the starfall.com site you had recommended had helped him tremendously....he knows all the alphabets and sound better than I do ;-) thanks to you!

Tamarind said...

Quote :
"I'm in the "panic" zone now ;-( and dont know how to help her besides "drilling" more assessment papers on vocab, grammar and comprehension which are something not enjoyable and killing her interest...any suggestions?"

During the meeting with my girl's teacher, though I was very happy with my girl's results, I asked the teacher how to study for English since my girl only brought back the workbook a few days before the exam ? The teacher said that if the child reads extensively, then there is no need to study the workbook.

My girl reads pages of more than one thousand words in English everyday, and she has been doing so since 5 years old.

My advise is to try to make use of the June holidays to read as much as possible. Check out these wonderful books :

Picture books from my home library

This is the most enjoyable way to learn English without killing the child's interest.

Also encourage her to write at least a few sentences everyday, of what she has done that day.

Anonymous said...

Thanks very much, will work on drumming up her interest in reading. Your collection of books are v interesting, will try to look it up in the library. :-)

Anonymous said...

Hi Tamarind,

In your front page you have given one tabular column in which you have mentioned under Phonics - Books 1 to 3 and under Key words 1a to 2c etc., I cannot understand what books and keywords refer. Please clarify that.

bye for now
Malar (India)

Tamarind said...

Dear Malar,
The "Key Words" column refer to the Peter and Jane books.
For example, Peter and Jane(key word) books 3a to 4c are suitable for kids 5 to 6 years old. This is a guide only, some kids may be more advanced and may be reading at higher levels.

The Phonics column refer to these books :
Phonics


The Read-it-yourself series refer to these books :
Read it yourself

Anonymous said...

Hi Tamarind,

My 2.5 yrs old boy seems to lose interest in learning the letter sounds. He knows most of the letter sounds but I feel that he does not know them well as he gets mixed up with the sounds at times. And so I test him after we read story books every night. But he does not like it and he will simply just answer me "I don't know".
How can I make sure that he knows all the sounds well, and not forgetting them? How should I proceed?

Thanks in advance.

Nelly

Tamarind said...

Hi Nelly,
Young kids normally do not like to be tested.

You can try to use these puzzles or DVDs :

First Step Teaching A B C

The Leapfrog DVD is excellent for teaching letter sounds, it is only 35 minutes, just play it once a day.

You can also try the www.starfall.com website.

Just be patient, there is no need to test the child. You can think of playing games with him instead. For example, try hiding a letter card and when he finds it, he must read out the letter.

Anonymous said...

Hi Tamarind,

How have u been? Is it the sch holidays now for u?

My 4 yr 3 mths old gal is at bk 11 of Peter n Jane now. It's difficult n like wat u said, we have to be very patient.

Is ur children reading any series books now? My kids are reading mostly English books borrowed from the library.

Take care for now....

Cheers... Melody

Anonymous said...

Hi Tamarind,

Thanks for your advice.

I just bought the alphabet floor puzzle to let him try out.

Btw I saw your post in KS forum about the Geo Trax set. I went down to Robinson and Taka last weekend but I cannot find it. Where did you get your set? Any idea where can I find it now?

Thanks in advance,
Nelly

Anonymous said...

Hi Tamarind,

I have been following your teaching methods religiously and started P&J with my girl when she was slightly 3. Now, at 3 yrs 9 mths, she is reading Bk 10. Although her comprehension level is definitely not on par with a 5 year old reading the same passage, I am glad that the daily reading routine has build her interest in reading. She picks up picture books (of level 4~6) to read at times.

Herewith, I'm writing a post of appreciation to you! Thanks for all your tips!

FYI, I'm also teaching her 45 kuai du.. It's good, and no Berries needed for now!

Cheers,
Dragonfly

Tamarind said...

Quote:
"Is ur children reading any series books now ?"

Hi Melody,
My kids are reading many series books now :
The Magic schoolbus chapter books
Astrosaurs
Jack Stalwart
Seekers by Erin Hunter
Animorphs
Box car children series
Goddess Girls
Wayside School series by Louis Sachar

My girl just finished reading The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien, a masterpiece that should be read by every child, and she loves it !

Tamarind said...

Quote:
"Btw I saw your post in KS forum about the Geo Trax set. I went down to Robinson and Taka last weekend but I cannot find it. Where did you get your set? Any idea where can I find it now?"

Hi Nelly,
I bought my sets from Robinson and Taka, they must be out of stock right now. It is available from www.amazon.com, though shipping from USA can be very expensive.

Tamarind said...

Hi Dragonfly,
Your girl is very impressive !

Yes it is very important to start with Si Wu Kuai Du now to ensure that she develops a love for Chinese as well.

Anonymous said...

Hi Tamarind,

Nice to hear your reply. Thks for sharing the list of books your children are reading now.

Hope to see more updates in ur blog when u have the time!!

Cheers... Melody

Shadus, Yating, Baby Shayne & Baby Sylvan said...

Hi,
May I know what is the first chapter book that u started yr child with after completing PJ12? Base on yr experience, Do u think it's too young for my gal who is 4 yr 4 mth old to start on roald Dahl books nw or should I wait?

Tamarind said...

Quote:
"May I know what is the first chapter book that u started yr child with after completing PJ12? Base on yr experience, Do u think it's too young for my gal who is 4 yr 4 mth old to start on roald Dahl books nw or should I wait?"

After completing Peter and Jane level 12, I let my daughter read Charlotte's Web which is considered the greatest children's book of all time. However, I don't recommend other 4 to 5 year old kids to read Charlotte's Web because there is not much action in this book. For my boy, it was My Father's Dragon, highly recommended for all 4 year old kids. At around 4 to 5 years old, both kids also read the original Wonderful Wizard of Oz and they love it. They also love Lafcadio The Lion Who Shot Back, and one mommy told me that her 4 year old girl absolutely loves this book.

Anonymous said...

Dear Tamarind,

 

First of all, thank you for your wonderful & informative blog, it's so helpful.
My question:
May I know am I putting following steps correctly? My son (4 yrs old) just finshed step 2.

 

STEPS:

1) Teaching ABC

2) Phonics

3) 3 Letters words [a,e,i,o,u]

4) Start up Keywords with P&J

5) th, sh, ch, wh, bl, cl, gl, fl, pl, br, cr, gr, fr, pr, tr, sl, st, sp, sm, sn, sw, sk, st, spr,scr

6) Long vowels

7) Silent "e"

7) Sight words

 

Actually I'm a bit confuse which one to teach first after the 3 letters words, as I have limited time daily to teach my kid too.
Kindly advice, thank you in advance.

Best regards,
Abbie
From Malaysia

Tamarind said...

Hi Abbie,
You are right about the steps !

You can teach Peter and Jane and step 5 to 7 concurrently. The sight words are actually taught in the Peter and Jane books. If you have limited time, try to focus on reading Peter and Jane everyday, teach steps 5 to 7 about three times a week.

Remember to ask your son to read every word out loud from the Peter and Jane books.

Anonymous said...

Hi Tamarind,

Hope all have been well with you n ur family! ;)

I am back for more advise from you again, my Shi Fu!

R ur kids still reading aloud to you these days?

Any tips on how do u coach ur kids on their work without attending enrichment classes?

Cheers.... Melody

Tamarind said...

Hi Melody,
My kids now read Chinese books out loud to me everyday. They are reading many English books on their own, so there is no need for them to read English to me.

Since they have a strong foundation in both English and Chinese, they do not need me to coach them in their school work. During the school holidays, I let them do some assessment books for the advanced topics. They can usually finish their work independently, I only correct their mistakes.

Anonymous said...

Hi Tamarind,

Thk u for ur reply!

What abt during sch term? Do u think it's necessary to do extra assessment bks then?

When would it be necessary to send the kids for tuition in ur opinion? It seems that a lot of kids these days go for tuition.

Cheers... Melody

Tamarind said...

Hi Melody,
If a child has a very good foundation in languages, and if the school gives a lot of homework, then personally I don't think it is necessary to do many assessment books during school term, or attend tuition classes.